On July 28, a group of Lakewood Ranch residents lined up along Manatee Avenue West in downtown Bradenton, all wearing red, holding yard signs displaying the slogan reported by the Business Observer: "Move the rink megaplex. Good project, wrong place." They weren't protesting hockey. Most of them said they liked the idea of an ice rink in East Manatee County. What brought them out for an 11-hour commission meeting was a proposal for an $80 million facility on county land next to their neighborhoods.
Here's what actually happened, and why the number that stopped it matters more than the ice.
What commissioners authorized, and how fast
According to the Your Observer, on June 16 Manatee County commissioners voted unanimously, with Commissioner Jason Bearden absent, to authorize the county administrator to move forward with a business transaction with Icemann Development LLC, a Wesley Chapel company that had already built the TGH Iceplex where the Tampa Bay Lightning train and the AdventHealth Center Ice in Wesley Chapel. The plan, known internally as Project Grace, called for a 190,000-square-foot multiplex on 22 acres of county-owned land at Premier Sports Campus North, just east of the Lakewood Ranch Library. Four ice rinks. A 2,500-seat arena. Restaurants, a pro shop, sports medicine services, and flooring that could cover the ice for volleyball, cheerleading, and consumer shows. Project leaders told commissioners it could open by 2028.
The proposed lease terms were phased over the first five years. The county would charge Icemann $1 a year for the first three years to let the company get the project off the ground, then $100,000 a year in year four, rising 2 percent annually starting in year five. Icemann CEO Gordon Zimmermann called Lakewood Ranch "our prized area that we've always wanted to be in" and told commissioners the Tampa Bay Lightning organization was "deeply excited" about the project, according to the Your Observer.
At the time, the vote drew almost no public pushback. Most residents didn't find out about the scale of it until weeks later.
What changed the outcome
By mid-July, that had shifted. Residents from Solera, Cresswind, Greyhawk Landing, and Indigo had organized three community meetings, emailed commissioners directly, and started a petition. By the July 28 meeting, that petition carried more than 1,200 signatures.
Residents also raised noise and traffic concerns, including for people whose kids wait at a Solera bus stop across the street from the proposed site. They also questioned whether the proposal fit the county's land development code. Jessica Wilson, a stay-at-home mom with ten years of experience in residential land development, read through Manatee County's zoning rules and found that Policy 2.10.2.2 caps medium commercial projects at 150,000 square feet of gross building area, as reported by the Your Observer. The proposed facility was 190,000 square feet, 27 percent over that cap.
Another resident, Theresa Keri, who advises Fortune 100 companies on risk management professionally, brought commissioners a 14-page risk assessment with probabilities, risk levels, and sourced comparisons to hockey facilities in other markets. Between the two of them, the argument stopped being "we don't like this" and became "this may not be allowed as written."
Commission Chair Tal Siddique told the room that the county did not want another project people discovered only after a deal was assembled, according to the Your Observer. Kathy Flora, one of the residents who organized the pushback and a retired three-term New Hampshire state representative, called the outcome "democracy in action," according to the Business Observer.
By the end of the meeting, commissioners voted unanimously to suspend negotiations with Icemann and directed county staff to explore alternative locations, including one Commissioner Bob McCann had floated earlier that month: relocating the project to land near the Bradenton Area Convention Center, which he argued already has the transit access and infrastructure Premier lacks.
The rink already paying property taxes
The pushback had a second layer that had nothing to do with zoning: a competing business owner who raised questions about the proposal's support.
Matt Smith owns the Ellenton Ice and Sports Complex, roughly 15 miles north of Premier, and has for ten years. He told commissioners he's paid nearly $1.2 million in property taxes over that decade and is now self-funding a $7 million expansion, adding a third ice sheet, without outside investors. The comparison below sets out the proposed support for Project Grace alongside Smith's investment in Ellenton.
Icemann Development (Project Grace) | Ellenton Ice and Sports Complex | |
|---|---|---|
Funding source | Public-private partnership, plus tourism development fund support Smith says totals $5 million | Entirely privately funded |
Land cost | $1/year for first three years, then $100,000/year in year four, rising 2% annually from year five | Owned outright |
Recent investment | $80 million estimated (Smith puts the real number closer to $110 million) | $7 million self-funded expansion, breaking ground January 2027 |
Track record locally | New to the market | Ten years, nearly $1.2 million paid in property taxes |
"It's just me and my family," Smith told commissioners. "There are no other people investing." He questioned how a facility Project Grace's size could break even before year six, the point at which maintenance costs typically climb.
This isn't Lakewood Ranch's first ice rink ambition
There's a reason some longtime residents greeted the Premier proposal with more skepticism than excitement. Lakewood Ranch already tried this once. Construction began in 2005 on the DVA Arena, a planned $70 million, 220,000-square-foot, 7,400-seat sports and entertainment complex at the corner of White Eagle Boulevard and Rangeland Parkway, as reported by the Your Observer. It was never finished. By 2009 the property had gone into foreclosure, and Schroeder-Manatee Ranch bought it back at auction and demolished the unfinished structure.
Florida's heat and humidity don't make ice rinks easy to run, either. Manatee County Commissioner Bob McCann noted in February, as reported by the Your Observer, that condensation can leave ice "soft, uneven and bumpy." None of that means Project Grace will fail. It does mean the area has a documented example of an unfinished large ice facility plan, which is part of why residents wanted a harder look before signing a 22-acre lease.
Where it stands now
As of mid-August, negotiations with Icemann remain suspended. County staff were directed to return to the commission with more information addressing the concerns raised at the July 28 meeting, though no firm date has been set for that follow-up. The Bradenton Area Convention Center site McCann proposed is one option on the table, but nothing has been finalized, and Icemann has not withdrawn from Lakewood Ranch entirely. The zoning cap Wilson identified hasn't been resolved either. It's simply the reason the county has to slow down and figure out whether the current site can legally support a project this size, or whether Project Grace needs a smaller footprint, a different location, or both.
For residents near Premier, the proposal moved through the county's tourism development channel rather than a standard rezoning hearing.
Lakewood Ranch changes shape every year, sometimes in ways residents get to weigh in on early and sometimes in ways they find out about after the fact. If you're trying to keep track of neighborhood developments, Susan L. Phelps covers it from the ground here. Search Homes to see what's currently available across Lakewood Ranch's villages while you're at it.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.
